POLICE ENCOUNTERS IN INDIA: A GRAVE CONCERN

November 28, 2023

Introduction

Encounters refer to situations where the police use excessive force or engage in extrajudicial killings, violating the rights of individuals and bypassing due process. Police encounters in India have been a subject of intense debate and concern for their potential violation of human rights and the rule of law.

Recent years have witnessed several high-profile encounters in India, raising concerns about their legitimacy and adherence to constitutional safeguards. Some notable instances include:

  • Hyderabad Encounter (2019): Four men accused of gang-raping and murdering a veterinarian were killed in an alleged encounter by the police. While it received public support, questions were raised about due process and the possibility of extrajudicial killings.
  • Uttar Pradesh Encounters (2017-2022): The state of Uttar Pradesh witnessed a significant number of encounters during this period, with the police claiming to have neutralized criminals involved in serious offenses.

The present article aims to examine the constitutional safeguards, statutory provisions, Supreme Court judgments, and potential regulatory measures to ensure accountability and prevent abuse.


Constitutional Safeguards against Encounters


The Constitution of India provides several fundamental rights and safeguards that aim to protect the life and liberty of individuals. These safeguards include

  • Article 21: The right to life and personal liberty, which encompasses the right to live with dignity and protection against arbitrary deprivation of life.
  • Article 22: The right against arbitrary arrest and detention, which includes the right to be informed of the grounds of arrest, the right to legal representation, and the right to be produced before a magistrate within 24 hours.
  • Article 20(3): The privilege against self-incrimination, ensuring that no person accused of an offense shall be compelled to be a witness against themselves.

Statutory Provisions regulating encounters

India has enacted specific laws to regulate police conduct and prevent abuse. Some relevant statutory provisions include:

  • The Indian Penal Code (IPC): Sections 96-106 deal with the right of private defense, allowing individuals to protect themselves from imminent harm. However, excessive use of force is not justified under this provision.
  • The Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC): Section 46 mandates that arrests must be made with reasonable force, avoiding unnecessary violence. Section 49 emphasizes that the arrested person must not be subjected to more restraint than necessary.
  • The Police Act, 1861: This Act provides guidelines for police behavior and accountability, emphasizing the need for professionalism, integrity, and respect for human rights.

Supreme Court Judgments on encounters


The Supreme Court of India has played a pivotal role in shaping the legal framework surrounding encounters and ensuring accountability. Some significant judgments include

  • People’s Union for Civil Liberties (PUCL) v. State of Maharashtra (2014): The court issued guidelines to be followed in cases of alleged fake encounters, emphasizing the importance of an independent investigation, compensation for victims, and prosecution of errant police officers.
  • Prakash Singh v. Union of India (2006): This landmark judgment directed the central and state governments to implement police reforms, including measures to ensure police accountability, transparency, and the establishment of police complaints authorities.
  • Om Prakash v. State of Jharkhand (2012): The court held that encounters must be subjected to thorough scrutiny and investigation to determine their genuineness. It emphasized that encounters cannot be a substitute for a proper investigation and trial.

How to regulate Police Encounters?

To ensure accountability and prevent abuse in encounters, several regulatory measures can be considered

  • Independent Investigation: Establishing an independent agency or commission to investigate encounter cases can ensure impartiality and transparency.
  • Training and Sensitization: Providing comprehensive training to police personnel on human rights, proper use of force, and non-lethal alternatives can help prevent excessive violence during encounters.
  • Oversight Mechanisms: Strengthening police oversight bodies, such as police complaints authorities or police reforms commissions, can enhance accountability and provide a platform for grievances.
  • Judicial Scrutiny: Encounters should be subjected to rigorous judicial scrutiny to determine their legality and genuineness. Independent magisterial inquiries can be conducted to assess the circumstances surrounding each encounter.

Conclusion
While encounters are often seen as a quick solution to combat crime, it is essential to uphold constitutional safeguards, adhere to statutory provisions, respect Supreme Court judgments, and regulate encounters to prevent abuse and protect the rights of individuals. By ensuring accountability and promoting transparency, India can strike a balance between maintaining law and order and safeguarding the principles of justice and human rights.

Significance of the Topic

The issue of fake encounters in India is a grave concern. Therefore, judiciary coaching suggest that the judicial aspirants must be aware of the issue of fake encounters, the constitutional safeguards and the statutory provisions. Judiciary coaching advice that the issue may be prepared with the essay perspective.

Leave a Comment